This is because a heavy watermelon indicated that it is full of water and therefore already nice and ripe.

This is also the same case with most fruits or vegetables.

Otherwise, a shiny watermelon means that it is not ripe enough.

How to Pick the Sweetest Watermelon Every Single Time

Image credit: Natural Ways via YouTube

How to Pick the Sweetest Watermelon Every Single Time

Easy Ripe Watermelon Picking Tips and Hacks

Easy Way to Pick Ripe Watermelon